A lot of people who are seeking the Captain With The Lover figurine to use as a cake topper, are very disappointed to find that it's been discontinued. Here are some other suggestions you may like:
Wooden Pin Custom Painted , like in the picture below:
Lego Cake Topper
Custom made from Clay toppers
Garden4Arts on Etsy has some really cute toppers. Maybe they can create what you are looking for.
Starting at $179, you could have one custom made to look like you (I love this the most), from
