I hunted around and found the best deal to be with http://www.sandartsupplies.com.

You can view their message bottles here:
http://www.sandartsupplies.com/StoreBox/message_bottles.htm

A lot of people who are seeking the Captain With The Lover figurine to use as a cake topper, are very disappointed to find that it's been discontinued. Here are some other suggestions you may like:

Lovely sail boat place holders! These could add some elegance to your pirate themed wedding. Just image them holding up a place card that is on an off white card stock, the sides have been burned to resemble old paper. You can burn the sides very easily with a wood burner (sold at most craft stores!).

Find the card holders here!

How gorgeous are these little ships? You could even personalize them yourself to be more pirate like if you wanted. I wish they had these when I got married!

Check them out here!

Grab one here!

This is an awesome ring! I think it would be really great as a gift to bridesmaids in a pirate wedding! Heck, I want one for myself!

You can find the ring here!

I love this cake topper. It's not pirate but it's beautiful! Maybe those who are looking for a topping could contact the artist and see if he could do a pirate themed one.